Tag: MMFF50

  • MMFF Movie Review: Though the First Two Acts Are Messy, ‘And the Breadwinner Is…’ Lands Its Ending

    MMFF Movie Review: Though the First Two Acts Are Messy, ‘And the Breadwinner Is…’ Lands Its Ending

    There’s a whole landscape of Filipino movies about the OFW experience as this is a phenomenon that has struck our society so deep. At some point, they have been called our present-day heroes. Films like ‘Anak’ and ‘Transit’ and ‘Hello Love Goodbye’ and the documentary ‘Sunday Beauty Queens’ are just some examples of films that tackle the emotional landscape of this set of people. So when director Jun Lana (co-writing with Daisy G Cayanan and Jumbo A. Albano) and Vice Ganda team up to tackle this narrative in an MMFF entry, it’s bound to get a lot of attention.

    This is my first Vice Ganda movie (I know, this is something I plan to fix by watching the rest of his filmography soon) so I wasn’t sure exactly what to expect. I’ve seen snippets of Vice on ‘It’s Showtime’ when it shows up on social media or when I’m on a bus and am familiar with his quick wit and razor sharp delivery of jokes. But to see it in action in a film is something else. The way the audience reacts to every punchline shows his mastery of comedy and that is unquestionable.
     
    ‘And the Breadwinner is…’ is the story of Bambi Salvador (Vice Ganda), an OFW working in Taiwan to help support her family in Pampanga. She works multiple jobs and has sacrificed their identity to build a house back at home that she and her family can truly call home. But the sudden death of one of her co-workers encourages her to return home early to be with the people that she loves only to find that her home has not been built and her family has wasted away all her money on failed businesses and frivolous things. In frustration and anger, she leaves home and is mistaken for dead. They discover that her life insurance would give the family ten million pesos and Bambi and her family decide that to pay off all their debt and start anew, Bambi would continue to pretend she’s dead.

    And The Breadwinner Is Movie Poster

    The first two acts of the film is messy, firing at all directions. There’s a feeling that each scene is more a skit, a gag, before moving to the next. The narrative’s flow is broken by these moments of humor. Each family member – from the younger brother Biboy (Jhong Hilario) and his wife Mayet (Gladys Reyes), to her even younger siblings Boy (Kokoy De Santos) and Buneng (Maris Racal), and her eldest sister Baby (Eugene Domingo), who had abandoned the family to live and work in Italy – gets to have their own story and while it’s an ensemble piece, at 123 minutes, it makes the film seem bloated as each one has just the same amount of story time to play out. Adding upon this is the deception plot regarding the insurance money as an inspector, Anton (Anthony Jennings), is trying to find out whether Bambi is truly dead or not.

    It’s a hodge-podge of scenes and gags that range from slapstick to witty comedy, bringing back characters from Vica Ganda’s filmography, and situational comedy that can hit or miss depending on the range of one’s taste. While the delivery is outstanding, there are jokes that make fun of fat people or ridiculing someone’s appearance and hurtful physical comedy that’s just not my cup of tea. But these elicit the most laughs because of Vice’s impeccable timing. 

    When the film slows down to become tender, especially when it’s geared towards the queer stories in the film; is when it gets touching. Joel Torre’s Popsie, the deceased patriarch of the family, has the most touching scenes in flashbacks. The way by which he adores Bambi is truly beautiful to see. The acceptance is something we need to see in films more to help normalize this. And the way by which Bambi returns that acceptance to Boy, who comes out to him creates a chain of kindness directed towards the community. It’s one of the more moving parts of this film handled expertly by Vice, Torre, and De Santos.

    But as messy as the first two acts are, the final act is when all that chaos is channeled into the film’s shift into drama. All the gags and the jokes, all of the misunderstandings and snide comments against each other, funnel into a confrontation of the whole family and Bambi ends up delivering an almost ten-minute monologue that embodies a whole lot of unsaid resentments from the OFW community. It’s a litany of the things that, as a culture, we are afraid to say out loud because we put family first before our own selves. It’s a magnificent space for Vice Ganda to show his acting chops as he throws out every emotion that feels like it has been trapped there forever, for the fifteen years that Bambi had suffered alone in another country. It’s visceral. It’s explosive. It’s done in a one-shot that puts Vice’s acting front and center. The whole movie was pushing towards this confrontation and it’s the reason why you should see this film.

    My Rating:

    stars 2 5



    And the Breadwinner Is… is now showing in cinemas. Check showtimes and buy your tickets here.

  • MMFF Movie Review: The Parts of ‘Isang Himala’ Are Stronger Than the Whole

    MMFF Movie Review: The Parts of ‘Isang Himala’ Are Stronger Than the Whole

    I was scared coming into ‘Isang Himala.’ I love the original film by Ishmael Bernal and Ricky Lee. I teach in my classes in Philippine Film History, and it is truly a groundbreaking work that still holds the test of time. I’m also in love with the stage adaptation by The Sandbox Collective, directed by Ed Lacson Jr. and music and lyrics by Vincent De Jesus. That production turned the whole stage, including the audience, into the town of Cupang and it was filled with incredible performances by its incredible cast. While the same cast is brought into the film adaptation of the musical, I feared that what made the stage play so magnificent – the way by which the whole town of Cupang comes alive and all the audience immerses themselves into the longing and desperation of that place – would be lost as it moves into the screen. How does a camera make the audience part of that world?

    But knowing that Pepe Diokno was coming in to direct gave me a little hope. After all, his ‘Gomburza’ was excellent. To differentiate his world from the stage play and the original film, Diokno shot the whole film on a studio, which allowed for full control of lighting and sound design and they could control the massive crowd scenes that inhabit this film. It gives the feeling of old school Hollywood musicals from MGM where the sets look too perfect, too manufactured and they bring this charming aesthetic to the narrative. I’m talking about ‘The Wizard of Oz’ or ‘Singing in the Rain’ or even ‘Seven Brides for Seven Brothers.’ There’s a leaning into the formalist tradition of cinema with Carlo Mendoza’s stunning cinematography turning the town of Cupang into the brilliant ochre shades that matches the film’s heavy tones and themes.

    Isang Himala STILLS 4

    ‘Isang Himala’ is about the town of Cupang, a town in need, ravaged by a drought, and the townsfolk believe that they are cursed. When Elsa (Aicelle Santos) proclaims she is having visions of the Virgin Mary and is seen healing a sick child, the town enters into a frenzy of religious fervor and zeal. A cult is quickly formed around her, tourists come from all over to receive Elsa’s blessings and healing, and the once-poor town suddenly gains a resurgence in economic growth. Factions are formed, as Elsa’s followers don’t take kindly to Nimia (Kakki Teodoro), who returns from Manila to open a cabaret while a documentary filmmaker, Orly (David Ezra), records Elsa’s movements, selling the footage and the photos he takes to newspapers in the city, while hoping to build a film about her. Elsa’s mother, Aling Saling (Bituin Escalante) is caught in the middle, a hapless observer as the town and her daughter are caught up in the madness of it all.

    Isang Himala STILLS 3

    There are so much great things happening in this movie. Diokno’s ability to really move that camera through that madness is riveting. He creates these large set pieces as the two transforms over the course of a song from impoverished to booming in minutes. The crowds come in and make the whole set come to life. The singing is exceptional. With performers like Santos, Escalante, Ezra, and Teodoro in the cast, there’s no question that we’ve got incredible vocals to go with Vincent De Jesus’ score. 

    Isang Himala STILLS 7

    But I felt so disconnected from the piece – a narrative that I’m in love with from its original film and its stage adaptation – and I realised that I find the adaptation of the stage musical into a film needed space and width. Cupang’s design is enclosed in canyon, everything is bunched up together and claustrophobic. Everyone is in everyone’s business. There’s a mass of people entering and exiting the scenes and the camera can come in close for the close-ups to capture the drama that is unfolding in this story. But the script does not illuminate the characters and their motivations clearly enough for us to warrant these close ups. The stage adaptation makes the whole town the central character and the audience is witnessing the transformation that it takes from the distance of spectator. We can’t really know these characters because of that distance. Here, the camera can come close. It gets intimate, but the script never really explores these characters inner worlds. I am left with no real clue on who Elsa is aside from the push and pull of people’s desires for her benediction nor do I really, truly understand what motivates Orly’s interest in her. If these are done through the songs (as most of the film is sung-through), it can get lost in the production of the music.

    Isang Himala STILLS 5

    The only character who truly shines and creates the film’s contrast is Nimia. While everyone is great, Kakki Teodoro fully embodies Nimia’s practicality and sense. Unlike everybody else, she believes in herself and is unafraid to stand up to her former friend. Teodoro brings this to the performance and sings the hell out of one of the best songs in the musical. Of all the characters in the film, hers is the clearest of what she wants and what she believes in. As I’m writing this, I heard that Teodoro won Best Actress at the MMFF Awarding and it is so well-deserved. Shes the one everyone is talking about when I left the cinema.

    Isang Himala STILLS 2

    At two hours and forty minutes, I felt exhausted. The film is an intense roller-coaster of powerful songs that lean more towards opera than it does to musicals. A lot of the songs aren’t melodic, which is fitting because there’s no real rhythm or melody to suffering. In the play, on just a piano, it is haunting. Here, it’s loud and aggressive. Played by a full band that makes each song feel like a finale. It’s big and the film never gets quiet enough to process all of the madness that happens within this town.

    Isang Himala Movie Review

    The claustrophobia and the lack of true character moments makes this world feel small. Whereas Ishmael Bernal’s use of wide empty spaces and long shots help creates that distance for the viewers so what we see is the town. Here, I see Elsa. I see Orly. I see Nimia. I see Aling Sepang. I see the characters but except for Nimia, I don’t really get to know them fully. So, I’m impressed by the performances, by the aesthetics and the filmmaking behind ‘Isang Himala’ but I’m left struggling with what I’m supposed to feel afterwards. It’s a heavy movie to take in but wonderfully made.

    My Rating:

    stars 2 5



    Isang Himala is now showing in cinemas. Check showtimes and buy your tickets here.